Saturday, 1 December 2007

Gregory of Rimini on the Eternity of the World

Gregory of Rimini's treatment of the paradoxes of infinity (S I.42-44.4) allowed him a swift response in S II.1.2.i to an Aristotelian argument that an endless world could not have had a beginning.

Here is the core of the Aristotelian argument:
Probatur minor, quia si detur oppositum, sequitur quod erit infinitum maius infinito. Nam tempus aeternum ex utraque parte super utrumque aeternum ex altera tantum addit reliquum tempus aeternum ex reliqua parte, ut super aeternum in praeterito tantum addit tempus aeternum in futuro tantum, et econverso. Cum igitur omne aeternum in futuro sit ens tempore infinito, sequitur quod fuit etiam ens infinito tempore praeterito.

And here is Gregory's response:
Ad secundam rationem principalem nego minorem, et dico quod probatio aeque militat contra Philosophum, qui posuit tempus aeternum in praeterito et in futuro, cum tamen aeternum in praeterito sit infinitum, et similiter aeternum in futuro, et aeternum ex utraque parte utrumque comprehendat. Quia tamen, secundum quod inferius dicam, possibile fuit tempus esse aeternum, quamvis de facto habuit initium, ac per hoc fuit possibile infinitum comprehendere in se plura infinita, dico quod hoc non est inconveniens, sicut in primo libro distinctione 44 declaratum est. Et pro nunc sufficiat exemplum de aliquo continuo, cuius utraque medietas continet infinitas partes proportionales alias ab his, quas reliqua continet.

The tu quoque here is a nice move.

8 comments:

Ocham said...

Nice to see you back, O brown one. I can't see a Latin blog getting a wide audience, however!

Best, Ockham

PS I think I have a digital copy of the Rimini's Sentences somewhere

Brunellus said...

Good point – I'll add translations when I next have a moment. (In both this and my post on the statutes, my immediate concern was to make these bits of text available online.)

Fangyaya said...

the north face outlet
moncler coat
louis vuitton outlet stores
cheap uggs
ray ban sunglasses
toms shoes uk
gucci outlet online
kate spade
kate spade outlet
adidas yeezy
michael kors bags
nfl jerseys wholesale
michael kors outlet online
pandora charms
hermes bags
adidas outlet store
retro jordans 13
true religion outlet
air jordan shoes
uggs sale
christian louboutin pas cher
beats by dre
michael kors canada outlet
rolex watches outlet
michael kors outlet clearance
michael kors handbags
longchamp outlet
ray ban sunglasses outlet
louis vuitton handbags
fitflop shoes
adidas originals store
gucci handbags
burberry handbags
fitflop sandals
ugg outlet
louis vuitton purses
abercrombie & fitch outlet
asics shoes for women
fitflops sale
ugg sale
20168.10chenjinyan

dada24 Xu said...

true religion jeans
ed hardy sale
ugg boots
coach outlet
ugg boots
coach outlet
canada goose outlet online
oakley sunglasses outlet
true religion outlet
nike factory store
2016107caiyan

eric yao said...

G Star Oakley Outlet Asics Shoes Bape Hoodie Stone Island Moncler Jackets Stone Island Jacket Calvin Klein Bally Shoes Chicago Bulls Jersey

anggita nirbaya said...

By taking the time to read a lot of information like this to add my insight . cara menggugurkan kandungan

Penyebab Kulit Tangan Mengelupas said...

Thank you very helpful article

Cara Mengobati Benjolan di leher
Cara Mengobati Penyakit Typus
Cara Mengobati bisul
Obat Benjolan Dimata
Obat Biang Keringat Pada Bayi Anak-anak dan dewasa
Obat Atasi Penyakit Gondongan

Cara Mengobati Tuba Falopi Tersumbat said...

Nice Article ;)

Pengobatan Atasi Penyakit Tiroiditis
Tips Mengobati Infeksi Rahim Secara Alami
Cara Mengobati Infeksi Kulit
Pengobatan Atasi Saraf Mata Rusak
Pengobatan Atasi Luka Lambung
Pengobatan Atasi Penyakit Ginjal Bocor