Thursday, 22 May 2008

Loveland on Auriol on Foreknowledge of the Sunrise

Jeff Loveland's article ‘Buffon, the Certainty of Sunrise, and the Probabilistic Reductio ad Absurdum’ (2001) contains a tantalizing reference to Auriol's take on foreknowledge of the sunrise in S I.30:

The authors Robert Holcot … and Peter de Rivo … – the latter perhaps influenced by Petrus Aureolus (Aureolus, 1312–20 [sic], pt. 1, p. 673) – were among those investigating the status of the assertion sol orietur cras – "the sun will rise tomorrow."  (p. 468)

Alas, if you follow this up in the 1596 edition, you'll find no such thing.  What's worse, the faulty reference doesn't look like a mere typo.  Here's something you will find on that page:

Quarta demum propositio est, quod relationi repugnat in communi ex sua ratione, quod sit res in natura existens.  Dicitur enim de ea, quod acquiritur, et oritur in fundamento sine sui mutatione, sola mutatione facta in termino.  Illud ergo non est res, quod acquiritur in subiecto nullo agente ipsum attingente; sed manifestum est, quod albo existente in oriente, si fiat aliud album in occidente, similitudo intelligitur in esse [inesse] albo, quod praeteriit in oriente, absque hoc, quod aliquod agens ipsum attingat, praeterquam intellectus, qui ipsum comparat ad album aliud, quod de novo producitur in occidente.  Non enim dealbans in occidente actionem suam protendit usque in oriens, et [ut] ibi similitudinem imprimit [imprimat], nec coelum, aut aliquid aliud potest impremere eam, nisi solus intellectus.  Ergo poni non potest, quod aliqua talis res fuerit acquista, et per consequens relationi ex sui natura repugnat habere existentiam in natura. (p. 673, col. 2, A–C)
(The variants are from Henninger's transcription of MS Borghese 329 – which wrongly has 'ullo' for 'nullo' – in his Relations, p. 154, n. 13.)

The context is the ontological status of relations, which Auriol takes to be mental constructs.  Here we find him defending his view with a thought experiment: if there is already a white thing in the east, and a white thing appears in the west, then the former acquires a similarity to the latter without any contact between the two.  (You might say that the pre-existing white thing undergoes a 'Cambridge change'.)

Now, someone could conceivably misconstrue this passage as having something to do with the sunrise.  But to do so he would have to read sola and solus as 'the sun' (rather than 'only') and oriens and occidens as 'rising' and 'setting' (rather than 'the east' and 'the west'); the former is indefensible, and the latter would make no sense in the context.

I hope this isn't the explanation – not just for academia's sake, but because I'd love to know what Auriol thinks about the necessity of the sunrise – but its ready availability would be a striking coincidence.


Fangyaya said...

the north face outlet
moncler coat
louis vuitton outlet stores
cheap uggs
ray ban sunglasses
toms shoes uk
gucci outlet online
kate spade
kate spade outlet
adidas yeezy
michael kors bags
nfl jerseys wholesale
michael kors outlet online
pandora charms
hermes bags
adidas outlet store
retro jordans 13
true religion outlet
air jordan shoes
uggs sale
christian louboutin pas cher
beats by dre
michael kors canada outlet
rolex watches outlet
michael kors outlet clearance
michael kors handbags
longchamp outlet
ray ban sunglasses outlet
louis vuitton handbags
fitflop shoes
adidas originals store
gucci handbags
burberry handbags
fitflop sandals
ugg outlet
louis vuitton purses
abercrombie & fitch outlet
asics shoes for women
fitflops sale
ugg sale

Nenden Yuniar said...

It is imperative that we read blog post very carefully. I am already done it and find that this post is really amazing.
obat gabagen
obat ginjal bengkak
obat keloid
obat limpa bengkak
obat thalasemia
obat kencing tidak tuntas
obat tbc tulang

Cara Mengobati Penyakit Cystitis said...

Thanks For Sharing Information

Pengobatan Untuk Mengangkat Kista Rahim
Cara Mengobati Abses Paru Tanpa Operasi
Pengobatan Untuk Batuk Kronis
Cara Alami Mengobati Empiema
Pengobatan Atasi Penyakit Vulvitis
Pengobatan Alami Untuk Mengangkat Tumor Hati

Pervez Joarder said...

This kind of excellent submits, I enjoy that. I need to point out in which, I’m extremely enthusiastic about the write-up. I am going to very happy when you can I want to learn concerning the posts. Today just click here best bathroom remodeling manhattan I do believe many individuals should the posts.

mary said...

نقل عفش الكويت شركة نقل عفش الكويت
فني صحي الكويت فني صحي الكويت
شركة تسليك مجارى الكويت شركة تسليك مجارى الكويت
سباك الكويت سباك الكويت